Part 1 of a 2-part series. Read Part 2.
[Gloria Benitez of Las Canadas, Honduras proudly shows off her new kitchen tap after 78 years of walking for water. Photo credit: Water1st International.]
In remote and impoverished communities around the world, I’ve heard new water systems described as a dream come true, winning the lottery, and God touching the Earth. There is no under-estimating the significance of the end to the all-consuming daily walk for water.
- Over 2 billion people still lack access to water that is safe to drink.
- Nearly 1 million people, mainly children under the age of 5, die each year from diarrhea.
- It is estimated that the world’s poorest households collectively spend $30 billion dollars annually on the treatment of preventable, water-related diseases.
- About 100 million children worldwide, mostly girls, receive no education at all because they are expected to carry water.
With 30% of the world’s population in need of clean, convenient water systems, there exists a tremendous opportunity for donors to have an impact on the lives of the world’s poorest people. But this is an issue that doesn’t just need greater investment, it needs smarter investment.
Unfortunately, water projects serving low-income households do not have a good track record. It is estimated that 35-50% of projects stop functioning within just two to five years of completion. There are many reasons that water projects fail, none of which are the ill-intentions of the organizations who build them. But the fact that this rate of failure has been unwavering for over thirty years, means that good intentions need to be backed by data and a commitment to quality control for the world’s poorest people.
People living in extreme poverty deserve a complete and sustainable solution, not a band-aid or an intermediary step, or the promise that one day someone will return to finally solve their water and sanitation problem.
In the water sector, the all-too-familiar and incomplete solution looks like the installation of a community handpump or home water filters. Water flowing from a household faucet is very uncommon, especially in rural, sub-Saharan Africa where the suffering associated with water collection is arguably the worst. Less than 10% of rural households in Africa have piped water on their premises. In Mozambique, I estimate it is less than 2%.
But handpumps are ubiquitous. There are more than a million of them on the African continent, and easily half are broken.
I recently attended the World Water Week conference in Stockholm, where one study of (mainly) handpump systems serving over one million people in five African countries, demonstrated that user fees covered just 25% of long-term operation and maintenance costs, which might explain why so many pumps are not repaired when they stop working. An insufficient fee structure sheds light on a couple of issues: one, that user fees were not established based on data-driven research, and, two, that users did not feel like they were getting a level of service worth paying for.
A users’ unwillingness to pay for operation and maintenance costs of a water system does not reflect my personal experience over the past 25 years. I have consistently found that when people have a high-quality water service, they will do everything to take care of it, and pay the full costs of maintenance.
A high level of water service looks very similar to the public utility serving your home, with 24/7 piped water to every single household; with a water meter installed at the home and a monthly water bill that supports the long-term maintenance of a system; with trained community members who manage their own system in perpetuity.
When water is available in the home, families experience a complete solution that includes a kitchen faucet, a toilet, and a shower. Not to mention, a cup of coffee, as Maria, a 78-year-old grandmother from Las Canadas, Honduras reminded me in January, “Now I begin my day with a cup of coffee rather than a walk for water.” Piped water ends the walk for water.
Donors have an important role to play in changing the status quo for the over 2 billion people stranded in extreme poverty, by not only carefully researching where they choose to invest, but by advocating for poor people without a voice. When donors demand that the water sector provide only the highest quality complete solutions, together, we will end the global water crisis.
The highest quality solutions might not be the least expensive, but this is not the time for bargain shopping. In the water sector, we need to move away from using cost/person to measure impact and instead invest in programs and projects that meet quantity and quality standards and have proven they are sustainable over the long-term. Up to $10 billion dollars are wasted annually as a result of poor investment decisions. If this funding were redirected to piped water systems, we could cover Sub-Saharan Africa in less than 20 years.
If only the highest-quality services are good enough for us, why aren’t they equally good for the home of a peasant farmer or a migrant in living in the urban slum settlements.
When we make smart investments up-front in the water sector, we set communities up to address other development needs. Once water is no longer the all-consuming focus of the day, girls can attend school, women can earn an income, and families can move beyond the grips of extreme poverty.
Water is the foundation. Let’s get it right the first time.
Original contribution by Marla Smith-Nilson, Founder and Executive Director of Water1st International.
Learning and benchmarking are key steps towards becoming an impact giver. If you are interested in giving with impact on Philanthropy (Other) take a look at these selections from Giving Compass.
Looking for a way to get involved?
Global is a fascinating topic, and others found these events, galas, conferences and volunteering opportunities aggregated by Giving Compass to be relevant for individuals with a passion for Global.
Are you ready to give?
Global is an important topic. Other members found these Giving Funds, Charitable Organizations and Projects aggregated by Giving Compass to be relevant to individuals with a passion for Global.