Giving Compass' Take:
- School transfer data is challenging to track, but school districts hide the number of disciplinary expulsions by transferring students involuntarily.
- How might school transfers harm students? What alternative disciplinary approaches can school districts use instead?
- Learn about preschool expulsions in schools.
What is Giving Compass?
We connect donors to learning resources and ways to support community-led solutions. Learn more about us.
While some educators defend transfers as a gentler alternative to expulsion, critics say these moves have limited or no due process protections and can carry the same problems associated with expulsion by disrupting a child’s education.
Despite policies that require California school districts to report the number of students transferred, the Department of Education’s overlapping and vague data reporting requirements mean it’s often unclear why a student changed schools.
State officials declined to provide any statewide data about transfers, saying a database in which they maintain the information is exempt from disclosure because it contains identifying information about students.
Read the full article about hidden expulsions by Tara Garcia Mathewson at The Hechinger Report.