With students everywhere back to school this month, education is at the top of mind for many. For donors interested in impact, early childhood education is an area that has demonstrated high returns on investment (ROI). We asked Lynn A. Karoly, PhD, a senior economist at the RAND Corporation and professor at the Pardee RAND Graduate School, a few questions on the topic of economic returns to early childhood programs.
What is one thing you would like donors interested in early childhood to know about the potential economic benefits associated with funding early childhood programs?
The first point I would make is that there is strong evidence of large potential economic returns to investing in high quality early childhood programs. But, that evidence, while very solid, doesn’t necessarily mean that every early childhood program will generate equally large returns. The evidence of substantial potential returns comes from high quality programs that often require a significant investment per child to implement. It can be tempting to think, “If it worked in that setting for a given expenditure per child and they achieved a strong economic return, maybe I can fund a program that costs half as much per child (because we don’t have the resources required to fund the more costly program) and still get half as much benefit.” But here’s where donors need to be cautious. Many programs likely have a “threshold” of quality and intensity that you need achieve if you are going to register positive returns. A related point is that the evidence regarding the strongest returns generally comes from programs working with children most at risk or who face the most disadvantages. That doesn’t mean that there may not be benefits to providing a program to children with more diverse backgrounds or for all children, but the returns per child served are not likely to be as high.
Do you have additional advice for donors who care about impact, and who might be choosing between different early childhood programs? How might research on the costs and benefits associated with different programs play into these decisions?
It makes sense to think about your specific objectives or area of interest, the populations you are hoping to serve, and other aspects of the context the program will be working in. I also think it is important to consider the evidence base as much as possible. One approach is to choose a proven program model and implement it with fidelity. If implementing a particular proven model in the given context is not possible, donors can still look for programs that reproduce key features or elements of programs that have been proven to be effective. And in addition to drawing from the evidence base, it is also important to contribute further to our knowledge of effective programs, through ongoing monitoring and evaluation of new program models or scale-up of proven programs. Ultimately, monitoring and evaluation is simply good practice for ensuring the quality of programs that are implemented and for verifying that you are obtaining the results you seek.
In terms of resources that investors can use to find programs that have an evidence base, the Center’s work is clearly one; there are also clearinghouses that have useful information about what has been proven to work. These include:
- Promising Practices Network
- Blueprints for Healthy Youth Development
- Coalition for Evidence Based Policy
- European Platform for Investing in Children (EPIC)
Anything else you would like to add?
Investing in early childhood programs has strong appeal for policymakers in the public sector, as well as investors in the private sector. I think there is tremendous opportunity for public-private partnerships with such investments, taking advantage of some of the newer funding mechanisms like Social Innovation Fund grants, social impact bonds, and other pay-for-performance mechanisms. These vehicles have the potential to unite the private donor community, non-profit sector, and government in realizing the economic and social returns to early childhood investments.
To learn more about how donors can invest in early childhood education, see the Center for High Impact Philanthropy’s toolkit, Invest in a Strong Start for Children.
Since you are interested in Impact Philanthropy, have you read these selections from Giving Compass related to impact giving and Impact Philanthropy?
Are you ready to give?
If you are looking for opportunities to take action and give money to Early Childhood, here are some Giving Funds, Charitable Organizations and Projects aggregated by Giving Compass where you can take immediate action.