Giving Compass' Take:
- Clarissa Chiu and Kim Garner discuss moving from a transactional mindset to meaningful transformation in rural philanthropy.
- What can donors and funders take away from the insights Garner gained from her time as an Education for Philanthropy Professionals participant for impactful rural philanthropy?
- Learn more about trends and topics related to best practices in giving.
- Search Guide to Good for purpose-driven nonprofits in your area.
What is Giving Compass?
We connect donors to learning resources and ways to support community-led solutions. Learn more about us.
Kim Garner serves as the Merced Regional Director at the Central Valley Opportunity Fund, a donor-advised fund housed within the Central Valley Community Foundation. Based in Merced, a small rural city where the nonprofit ecosystem is still taking shape, Kim supports grassroots organizations tackling issues like permanent shelter for the unhoused, workforce development, and especially youth development, moving towards transformation in rural philanthropy. Many of the region’s community-based organizations are in the early stages of development, where they are passionate but under-resourced, and still building fundamental infrastructure.
“I loved the program,” Kim shares. “It helped me move away from a charitable grant based, transactional mindset to thinking about long-term systems change.”
“The community-based organizations here are incredibly under-resourced,” Kim explains. “Many organizations are grassroots, overlapping in mission, and still building the basics, like how to put together an effective board or properly file a 990 form. We’re really in the early stages of growing a nonprofit ecosystem.” But supporting these organizations isn’t just about writing checks—it requires strategic, long-term thinking. That’s what led Kim to our Education for Philanthropy Professionals (EPP) program.
The program helped shift her mindset from a short-term, grant-by-grant focus to a more systemic, long-range approach rooted in strategy and accountability. Through tools like causal loop diagrams and systems mapping, she gained a deeper understanding of the interconnected challenges facing communities like Merced, and new ways to think about leverage points for change.
One of the key takeaways for Kim was the value of stepping back to reflect. In a region with limited philanthropic infrastructure, day-to-day demands can easily overwhelm the ability to think long-term. EPP offered a rare opportunity to pause, learn, and connect.
“It gave me a new lens to think about community issues and where we can support for real impact.”
In addition to the curriculum, Kim found the diversity of the cohort particularly powerful. The combination of virtual learning and in-person sessions created space for shared experiences across geographies, roles, and perspectives, which she noted is especially meaningful for those working in more isolated rural areas to bring about transformation in rural philanthropy.
Kim believes the moment is urgent. With public funding shrinking and community needs growing, philanthropy has a unique responsibility to step forward, not just with dollars, but with clarity, intentionality, and a willingness to take risks.
Read the full article about transformation in rural philanthropy by Clarissa Chiu at Stanford Center on Philanthropy and Civil Society.