What is Giving Compass?
We connect donors to learning resources and ways to support community-led solutions. Learn more about us.
Giving Compass' Take:
• Bandiera at al. explored the role of social ties in delivering development aid and found that they may reinforce inequalities in development programs.
• How can global development funders use this information to improve the delivery of aid?
• Learn more about achieving better results in global development.
In village economies, dense social networks support cooperation and exchange between citizens. The global shift towards hiring agents from within communities to deliver programs implies that the networks these agents are embedded in may affect delivery.
We examine this using a randomized evaluation of an agricultural extension program in Uganda where we randomly pick one of two potential local delivery agents and map ties between delivery agents and farmers, between delivery agents and between farmers.
Consistent with a model of favor exchange in social networks we find that (i) farmers tied to the chosen delivery agent are more likely to be treated than those tied to the counterfactual agent, (ii) this preferential treatment disappears when the two potential agents are tied by friendship, family or politics and (iii) when this is not the case the delivery agent actively prevents program benefits from diffusing to the ties of of the counterfactual agent. These results reveal the deep influence that social networks have on program delivery and help us to understand the highly unequal pattern of effects of the program both within and across villages.
These results starkly highlight three things. The first is that the same program will have radically different impacts depending on the structure of social networks that the local agent is embedded in. The second is that pre-existing social divisions may lead to a dissonance between the objectives of the development agency and local agent. The third is that these divisions may exacerbate rather than reduce existing inequalities.