Giving Compass' Take:
- An excerpt from Mario Marazziti's book, 13 Ways of Looking at the Death Penalty, asserts that the death penalty promotes a "culture of death" and has no place in a modern justice system.
- What are the consequences of a justice system that has the power to put people to death? How can funders help to shape a more just criminal justice system?
- Read about philanthropy and the death penalty.
What is Giving Compass?
We connect donors to learning resources and ways to support community-led solutions. Learn more about us.
Capital punishment is the culmination of violence at both ends of society: the violence of the individual criminal, who is caught in a cycle of violence and whose life ends in a violent death; and the violence of the state, with its police forces and wars whose ultimate expression is the use of violent death as a form of retributive justice. It is a legitimization of the culture of death from the highest level of worldly authority.
The death penalty is ineffective as a deterrent for crime, though it can be used very effectively as a way for religious majorities to oppress minorities, eliminate political adversaries, create terror, and spread worldwide propaganda, as ISIS has shown when it makes headlines across the globe with its beheadings in Syria and Iraq. It is not a tool of justice because it always affects religious, social, racial, and ethnic minorities in unjust, disproportionate ways. It is a form of torture in the way it forces the condemned to ponder the end of his or her life, often for years, before it finally comes.
The death penalty is not merely unnecessary in light of the alternative instruments of punishment and justice available. In truth, it is not itself an instrument of justice at all; it is a grave weakness in a system of justice that should preserve its rehabilitative intent, free of the primitive need for revenge and retribution. It winds up being not only a violation of human life, but a humiliation for everybody.
It seems clear to us that capital punishment is a practice to be overcome in the history of mankind, as slavery has been largely overcome. It’s possible to envision a world in which capital punishment no longer exists.
Read the full article about abolishing the death penalty by Mario Marazziti at YES! Magazine.